Gonka Community Fund

Нужны правкиAI-черновик

Framework score v2

Простое ревью

This should not be funded in its current form because it describes a plausible community media activity but lacks a funding amount, measurable outputs, acceptance criteria, budget logic, and verifiable evidence of prior impact.

Доказательства

низкие

Команда

есть вопросы

Блокеры

Почему такое мнение

The activity may be useful, but the proposal does not define what the fund is buying.
The funding request cannot be evaluated because the amount and budget are missing.
Prior work and impact claims are not supported with links or metrics.

Пять публичных проверок

1/4

Ценность для сети

Gonka news, education, and interviews could help the network, but no concrete audience need, distribution plan, or timing rationale is evidenced.

1/4

Ясность плана

The plan says the team will continue video production but gives no episode count, schedule, formats, quality bar, languages, or verification method.

1/4

Доверие к команде

Slava MSE is identifiable, but the proposal does not verify prior videos or show the team capacity for the requested three-month scope.

0/4

Дисциплина финансирования

The requested amount is unknown and there is no budget, milestone, tranche, or opportunity-cost explanation.

1/4

Риски и stewardship

The proposal provides contact details but does not address conflicts, content rights, moderation risks, reporting, or asset handover.

Оценка команды

There is a reachable proposer, but accountability and delivery evidence for this exact grant are under-specified.

Ответственный

ок

The tender names Slava MSE and provides Discord and email contact details.

Релевантные доказательства

вопрос

The proposal claims prior news, education videos, and interviews but provides no direct links or performance evidence.

Ресурсы и capacity

неясно

The proposal does not state team members, workload, production cadence, or available equipment and time.

Accountability path

вопрос

There is a contact path but no reporting cadence, acceptance process, or escalation mechanism.

Условия

State the exact GNK or other currency amount requested for the three-month period.
Provide a budget broken down by production, editing, translation, design, distribution, and any contractor costs.
Define deliverables such as number of videos, minimum length, formats, publication channels, release cadence, and languages.

Блокирующие проблемы

Нет измеримого результата: The only provided metric is a tender vote tally, which is not a network outcome.
Нет бюджетной или tranche-логики: The ask is listed as 0 UNKNOWN and no budget structure is provided.
Ключевые утверждения не подтверждены: Prior production and community usefulness are asserted without links, analytics, or examples.

8. Team Gonka.TV Grant Request

Что говорит ревью

Что думает коммьюнити

Ваше мнение

О чем это

Простое ревью